It wasnt a challenge, it was to show the validation of why the regsubex was not needed that in the longer sloppy way that did it achieved the goal you wanted and was less code then adding the regsubex in., tho if you want to do a code challenge I am More then game to see how small, Yet most usable the snippet is in the end. tho I think I would like to go for something that is more of a challenge that will really make myself think.